Criminal Minds’ interrogation scenes get this wrong

Within the Criminal Minds season 2 episode, “The Boogeyman,” Derek Morgan (Shemar Moore) interrogates James Charles (Sean Bridgers). Even though Morgan does not lay a finger on Charles, his perspective may be very confrontational, and he teases and provokes the person till the location begins escalating and the suspect turns into agitated. In keeping with Fleck, Morgan’s aggression is an issue. “Confessions should be voluntary and can’t be coerced, in a different way they are going to be excluded from proof,” he says. 

Positive, it is true that Morgan does not in fact lay a finger at the suspect, however Fleck issues out that there are lots of techniques to be threatening. “It’s imaginable to threaten violence with out phrases, or even threatened violence is according to se coercive. As well as, Morgan used mental coercion. Whilst confessions that end result from mental coercion aren’t robotically excluded from proof, the pass judgement on would decide whether or not the mental ploys have been so coercive that the confession used to be involuntary and unreliable.”

Some other match in a equivalent vein takes position within the season 7 episode, “The Corporate,” during which Morgan totally loses his cool whilst interrogating Malcolm Ford (Chad L. Coleman), and has an outburst all over which he obviously threatens the suspect. Fleck feels that this interrogation maneuver used to be quite unhealthy, regardless that it did reason the suspect to slide up. “In this snippet, I assumed Morgan’s emotional outburst used to be dangerous however efficient,” he opines.

Leave a Comment